Accendo Reliability

Your Reliability Engineering Professional Development Site

  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
  • Reliability.fm
    • Speaking Of Reliability
    • Rooted in Reliability: The Plant Performance Podcast
    • Quality during Design
    • Critical Talks
    • Dare to Know
    • Maintenance Disrupted
    • Metal Conversations
    • The Leadership Connection
    • Practical Reliability Podcast
    • Reliability Matters
    • Reliability it Matters
    • Maintenance Mavericks Podcast
    • Women in Maintenance
    • Accendo Reliability Webinar Series
    • Asset Reliability @ Work
  • Articles
    • CRE Preparation Notes
    • on Leadership & Career
      • Advanced Engineering Culture
      • Engineering Leadership
      • Managing in the 2000s
      • Product Development and Process Improvement
    • on Maintenance Reliability
      • Aasan Asset Management
      • CMMS and Reliability
      • Conscious Asset
      • EAM & CMMS
      • Everyday RCM
      • History of Maintenance Management
      • Life Cycle Asset Management
      • Maintenance and Reliability
      • Maintenance Management
      • Plant Maintenance
      • Process Plant Reliability Engineering
      • ReliabilityXperience
      • RCM Blitz®
      • Rob’s Reliability Project
      • The Intelligent Transformer Blog
    • on Product Reliability
      • Accelerated Reliability
      • Achieving the Benefits of Reliability
      • Apex Ridge
      • Metals Engineering and Product Reliability
      • Musings on Reliability and Maintenance Topics
      • Product Validation
      • Reliability Engineering Insights
      • Reliability in Emerging Technology
    • on Risk & Safety
      • CERM® Risk Insights
      • Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications
      • Operational Risk Process Safety
    • on Systems Thinking
      • Communicating with FINESSE
      • The RCA
    • on Tools & Techniques
      • Big Data & Analytics
      • Experimental Design for NPD
      • Innovative Thinking in Reliability and Durability
      • Inside and Beyond HALT
      • Inside FMEA
      • Integral Concepts
      • Learning from Failures
      • Progress in Field Reliability?
      • Reliability Engineering Using Python
      • Reliability Reflections
      • Testing 1 2 3
      • The Manufacturing Academy
  • eBooks
    • Reliability Engineering Management DRAFT
  • Resources
    • Accendo Authors
    • FMEA Resources
    • Feed Forward Publications
    • Openings
    • Books
    • Webinars
    • Journals
    • Higher Education
    • Podcasts
  • Courses
    • 14 Ways to Acquire Reliability Engineering Knowledge
    • Reliability Analysis Methods online course
    • Measurement System Assessment
    • SPC-Process Capability Course
    • Design of Experiments
    • Foundations of RCM online course
    • Quality during Design Journey
    • Reliability Engineering Statistics
    • An Introduction to Reliability Engineering
    • An Introduction to Quality Engineering
    • Process Capability Analysis course
    • Root Cause Analysis and the 8D Corrective Action Process course
    • Return on Investment online course
    • CRE Preparation Online Course
    • Quondam Courses
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Live Events
  • Calendar
    • Call for Papers Listing
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Webinar Calendar
  • Login
    • Member Home

by Doug Lehr 2 Comments

Failure Analysis or Failure to Analyze?

Failure Analysis or Failure to Analyze?

“A failure analysis is a waste of resources. We know why it failed. We need to move on.”

If you have participated in a failure analysis, you have likely heard the preceding comments, and been told to fix the problem ASAP. You make a change, but the same failure re-surfaces and you are in the hot seat again. What can you do to improve the failure analysis process in the future? Let us begin by reviewing some realities of failures.

A failure can be very costly. The costs of developing an improved product and replacing defective products add up quickly. Failure can also result in brand damage, a cost which includes lost sales and future discounts.

A failure analysis interrupts the organization. Pulling your best and brightest into the analysis puts other projects on hold, leading to opportunity cost.

As an example, consider the following scenario. An oilfield product is leaking in a customer’s well. The investigation reveals that it contains a cracked seal. The multi-disciplinary failure analysis team focuses on the cracked seal, designing and testing new versions. The team gets a new seal to pass a test. The product is put back in service, but the leak occurs again. The team’s approach indicates a Failure to Analyze.

 TRUTH: A failure becomes more costly when the failure analysis is conducted poorly.

The cracked seal may be a symptom of another problem. The Failure Analysis should use a method such as the 5 Whys Root Cause Analysis, in which “why” is asked at least 5 times. Begin by asking why the failure occurred. Use the answer to this question to create the second question, and so on, until you have asked and answered at least 5 questions. For example:

  • Why did the product leak? The seal cracked.
  • Why did the seal crack? Because of high volumetric expansion.
  • Why was volumetric expansion high? Because an incompatible fluid in the well caused excessive seal swelling.
  • Why was an incompatible fluid in the well? Because the fluids program was changed at the wellsite and we were not consulted about seal compatibility.
  • Why were we not consulted about seal compatibility? Because the management of change process was not used. This is the true ROOT CAUSE.

This process of asking “Why” at least 5 times identified the true root cause. Find the root cause and you know which problem to fix.

Filed Under: Articles, Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications, on Risk & Safety

« 5 Ways To Improve Reliability Of Performed Maintenance Work
Root Cause Analysis vs. Shallow Cause Analysis: What’s the Difference? »

Comments

  1. Francilei Pereira says

    December 13, 2020 at 9:32 AM

    Great post! Simple and straightforward to the point Fred!

    Reply
    • Doug Lehr says

      December 14, 2020 at 5:43 AM

      Thank you for your feedback on my article!

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Articles by Doug Lehr, P.E., Founder and Principal, Integris Technology
in the Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications series

Join Accendo

Receive information and updates about articles and many other resources offered by Accendo Reliability by becoming a member.

It’s free and only takes a minute.

Join Today

Recent Articles

  • History Repeats Itself: Buncefield, Puerto Rico, Jaipur
  • How Reliability Engineers Can Improve Their Communication in Information Sessions
  • FMEA Detection Risk: Insights and Advices
  • How to Structure Your ERM System
  • Rate of Occurrence of Failure

© 2023 FMS Reliability · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies to give you a better experience, analyze site traffic, and gain insight to products or offers that may interest you. By continuing, you consent to the use of cookies. Learn how we use cookies, how they work, and how to set your browser preferences by reading our Cookies Policy.