Accendo Reliability

Your Reliability Engineering Professional Development Site

  • Home
  • About
    • Contributors
  • Reliability.fm
    • Speaking Of Reliability
    • Rooted in Reliability: The Plant Performance Podcast
    • Quality during Design
    • Critical Talks
    • Dare to Know
    • Maintenance Disrupted
    • Metal Conversations
    • The Leadership Connection
    • Practical Reliability Podcast
    • Reliability Matters
    • Reliability it Matters
    • Maintenance Mavericks Podcast
    • Women in Maintenance
    • Accendo Reliability Webinar Series
    • Asset Reliability @ Work
  • Articles
    • CRE Preparation Notes
    • on Leadership & Career
      • Advanced Engineering Culture
      • Engineering Leadership
      • Managing in the 2000s
      • Product Development and Process Improvement
    • on Maintenance Reliability
      • Aasan Asset Management
      • CMMS and Reliability
      • Conscious Asset
      • EAM & CMMS
      • Everyday RCM
      • History of Maintenance Management
      • Life Cycle Asset Management
      • Maintenance and Reliability
      • Maintenance Management
      • Plant Maintenance
      • Process Plant Reliability Engineering
      • ReliabilityXperience
      • RCM Blitz®
      • Rob’s Reliability Project
      • The Intelligent Transformer Blog
    • on Product Reliability
      • Accelerated Reliability
      • Achieving the Benefits of Reliability
      • Apex Ridge
      • Metals Engineering and Product Reliability
      • Musings on Reliability and Maintenance Topics
      • Product Validation
      • Reliability Engineering Insights
      • Reliability in Emerging Technology
    • on Risk & Safety
      • CERM® Risk Insights
      • Equipment Risk and Reliability in Downhole Applications
      • Operational Risk Process Safety
    • on Systems Thinking
      • Communicating with FINESSE
      • The RCA
    • on Tools & Techniques
      • Big Data & Analytics
      • Experimental Design for NPD
      • Innovative Thinking in Reliability and Durability
      • Inside and Beyond HALT
      • Inside FMEA
      • Integral Concepts
      • Learning from Failures
      • Progress in Field Reliability?
      • Reliability Engineering Using Python
      • Reliability Reflections
      • Testing 1 2 3
      • The Manufacturing Academy
  • eBooks
    • Reliability Engineering Management DRAFT
  • Resources
    • Accendo Authors
    • FMEA Resources
    • Feed Forward Publications
    • Openings
    • Books
    • Webinars
    • Journals
    • Higher Education
    • Podcasts
  • Courses
    • 14 Ways to Acquire Reliability Engineering Knowledge
    • Reliability Analysis Methods online course
    • Measurement System Assessment
    • SPC-Process Capability Course
    • Design of Experiments
    • Foundations of RCM online course
    • Quality during Design Journey
    • Reliability Engineering Statistics
    • An Introduction to Reliability Engineering
    • An Introduction to Quality Engineering
    • Process Capability Analysis course
    • Root Cause Analysis and the 8D Corrective Action Process course
    • Return on Investment online course
    • CRE Preparation Online Course
    • Quondam Courses
  • Webinars
    • Upcoming Live Events
  • Calendar
    • Call for Papers Listing
    • Upcoming Webinars
    • Webinar Calendar
  • Login
    • Member Home

by Carl Carlson 2 Comments

FMEA Q and A – Application of Generic FMEAs

FMEA Q and A – Application of Generic FMEAs

FMEA Q and A

Is it a good idea to do one generic FMEA for wiring harnesses, and use it as a reference for other FMEAs for similar applications? What about interfaces? These questions are discussed and  answered in this FMEA Q and A article.

“We live in the world our questions create.”
David Cooperrider

Reader’s Question

First, let me say I am enjoying your book. We are looking at doing a DFMEA on wire harnesses for a particular type of farm equipment. We would like to do one generic FMEA on harnesses, and use it as a reference for other FMEAs, since we typically cover the signal requirements for control and feedback in the different system FMEAs. What are your thoughts?

Answer to Reader’s Question

I’m glad you are enjoying the book. Regarding your question on wiring harnesses, here are my thoughts. As you suggest, the wiring harnesses can be combined into one good Design FMEA, which can be the repository for the functions, failure modes, effects, causes, and controls for a generic wiring harness. This is provided the various wiring harnesses are similar enough to be included in one FMEA. Generic FMEAs can save time and improve FMEA effectiveness, provided they are done correctly, and provided the FMEA team pays attention to certain application issues. The interfaces between the wiring harnesses and other components and subsystems, both software and hardware, must be taken into account. The signal communications can be included (as you say) in a properly done System FMEA, or in a separate Software FMEA. The hardware interfaces must be included somewhere, either in Subsystem FMEAs or in other FMEAs. The key is to “make it visible”: FMEA Block Diagrams, P-Diagrams, Functional Block Diagrams, FMEA Interface Diagrams, as covered in chapter 5 of my book. With visible diagrams, you can be sure that all interfaces and functions are properly covered. Let me know if you have any other questions.

Next Article

Why do we limit entries into the prevention or detection control column to actions or methods that are currently planned or in place? In the next article, the essential elements of FMEA Controls are presented.

Filed Under: Articles, Inside FMEA, on Tools & Techniques

« 3 Steps to Reduce the Meetings of a Maintenance Professional
Making the most of FMEA »

Comments

  1. Hilaire Perera says

    November 17, 2017 at 3:58 PM

    Failure mechanisms are the processes by which physical, electrical, chemical and mechanical stresses induce failure. Knowledge of the failure mechanisms that cause product failure is essential to design and qualify reliable products. The standard Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (FMEA) and Failure Modes, Effects and Criticality Analysis (FMECA) procedures do not identify the product failure mechanisms and models, which limits their applicability to provide a meaningful input to critical procedures such as virtual qualification, root cause analysis, accelerated test programs, and to remaining life assessment.

    Failure Modes, Mechanisms and Effects Analysis (FMMEA) enhances the value of FMEA and FMECA by identifying high priority failure mechanisms and failure models. High priority failure mechanisms determine the operational stresses, and the environmental and operational parameters that need to be controlled. Models for the failure mechanisms help in the design and development of a reliable product.

    Center for Advanced Life Cycle Engineering (CALCE) has developed the FMMEA process and helped several organizations implement the tool in their product development process

    Reply
    • Carl Carlson says

      November 18, 2017 at 8:40 AM

      Hello Hilaire. Thanks for your well thought out comments about the value of including failure mechanisms in FMEA. I completely agree! I always teach that higher-risk issues in an FMEA must be taken to root cause and failure mechanisms. And I make this point in detail in my book. A also have a section in chapter 15 of my book on FMMEA, and have worked with colleagues at CALCE on FMMEA papers and dialog. FMMEA does exactly as you say.
      One point about your comment. One of the most well-known FMEA references is AIAG 4th edition. On page 39 there is a section on “Potential Mechanism(s) of Failure Mode”, which defines failure mechanisms and how to use them in FMEA procedure. However, as you point out, the FMEA standards to not discuss the modeling of failure mechanisms, which is important.
      Have you used FMMEA? I’d be interested in any comments on the application.
      Carl

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Articles by Carl Carlson
in the Inside FMEA series

Information about FMEA Icon

Inside FMEA can be visually represented by a large tree, with roots, a solid trunk, branches, and leaves.

– The roots of the tree represent the philosophy and guiding principles for effective FMEAs.
– The solid trunk of the tree represents the fundamentals for all FMEAs.
– The branches represent the various FMEA applications.
– The leaves represent the valuable outcomes of FMEAs.
– This is intended to convey that each of the various FMEA applications have the same fundamentals and philosophical roots.

 

For example, the roots of the tree can represent following philosophy and guiding principles for effective FMEAs, such as:

1. Correct procedure         2. Lessons learned
3. Trained team                 4. Focus on prevention
5. Integrated with DFR    6. Skilled facilitation
7. Management support

The tree trunk represents the fundamentals of FMEA. All types of FMEA share common fundamentals, and these are essential to successful FMEA applications.

The tree branches can include the different types of FMEAs, including:

1. System FMEA         2. Design FMEA
3. Process FMEA        4. DRBFM
5. Hazard Analysis     6. RCM or Maintenance FMEA
7. Software FMEA      8. Other types of FMEA

The leaves of the tree branches represent individual FMEA projects, with a wide variety of FMEA scopes and results.

Join Accendo

Receive information and updates about articles and many other resources offered by Accendo Reliability by becoming a member.

It’s free and only takes a minute.

Join Today

Recent Posts

  • History Repeats Itself: Buncefield, Puerto Rico, Jaipur
  • How Reliability Engineers Can Improve Their Communication in Information Sessions
  • FMEA Detection Risk: Insights and Advices
  • How to Structure Your ERM System
  • Rate of Occurrence of Failure

© 2023 FMS Reliability · Privacy Policy · Terms of Service · Cookies Policy

This site uses cookies to give you a better experience, analyze site traffic, and gain insight to products or offers that may interest you. By continuing, you consent to the use of cookies. Learn how we use cookies, how they work, and how to set your browser preferences by reading our Cookies Policy.